According to one dictionary, Critique (n) An essay or article that gives a critical evaluation (as of a book or play).
Nowhere does it say, be derogatory, be nasty, insulting, or just say, it’s nice.
A critique should be:
Constructive – as a reader, reading the book, what stands out as something that seemed to make the book less enjoyable than others you’ve read:
Were characters fully flesh and blood character you had empathy for?
Was the dialogue artificial or did it seem real?
What seemed right or off about the setting, if the author mentions a town, someone might live or has lived there and knows the area well.
Anything that makes the reader halt, quandary, or stumble over something in a book, that is a point for a constructive criticism and noted in a critique.
A critique is unlike a review in many ways. Writing a critique is not easy to write.
Critiques can be a spectacular tool for authors.
The sandwich method critique, begin with something affirmative, followed by what the reader deems wrong, followed by something affirmative.
Authors need to park their ego at the door and listen to honest critiques because if may help them improve.
Freelance Writer, Blogger, Editor, Proofreader, and Reviewer learning Marketing
Follow the author: http://xeeme.com/RobertMedak
- Dos and Donts of Giving a Book Critique (amandabumgarner.com)
- Trick-Or-Critique Competition (baconbooks.wordpress.com)
- College Advice: Key Tips for Writing a Critique Essay (psych.answers.com)
- How to Write a Critique (ravenpierce.wordpress.com)
- Clarifying Between Bullying and Critiquing Book Reviews (fallsintowriting.com)